AI Marketing and Buyer Trust: Lessons from Gee Ranasinha

By The Leadership Match

Gee Ranasinha explains how generic AI marketing can weaken buyer trust—and how leaders can replace inflated claims with specific, verifiable evidence.

AI Marketing and Buyer Trust: Lessons from Gee Ranasinha

AI Marketing and Buyer Trust: Why Faster Content Needs Better Judgment Lessons from Gee Ranasinha on marketing psychology, credible communication, and creating customer value By Martin Rowinski | The Leadership Match Your marketing says you are innovative, customer-focused, and different. But your prospect has already read almost the same paragraph on three other websites. What have you actually given them a reason to believe? That question sits at the center of my conversation with Gee Ranasinha, a keynote speaker on marketing and buyer psychology, on The Leadership Match. We explored how buyers form judgments, why generic communication can weaken credibility, and what leaders should consider before using AI to produce more marketing. Gee’s concern was not simply that businesses are adopting new tools. It was that speed can become the objective while standards receive less attention. “Most businesses, most leaders are using AI to get faster, but not better.” That was Gee’s assessment of the behavior he sees around him, rather than a statistical claim. It captures the leadership question running through our discussion: Is your marketing becoming more useful to buyers, or merely easier to produce? What Is “AI Slop” in Marketing? In this article, “AI slop” refers to generic, weakly reviewed AI-generated material that adds little useful information: interchangeable paragraphs, inflated claims, repetitive messaging, or visuals that feel disconnected from the business they represent. The issue is the quality of the result and the judgment behind it. An AI-assisted draft can become useful content when it is grounded in real knowledge, checked carefully, and shaped around a buyer’s needs. Human-written marketing can also be vague, exaggerated, or unhelpful. For leaders, the relevant question is what the finished work communicates about the company. Does it demonstrate understanding? Does it contain evidence? Does it help someone make a decision? Or does it ask the reader to accept a polished claim without support? Those questions provide a more meaningful quality standard than how quickly the content was created. Buyer Psychology: Help People Evaluate Instead of Asking Them to Believe Gee traced an important influence on his approach to a former sales director who was exceptionally observant about human behavior. By accompanying him on sales calls, Gee learned how to help buyers think through a problem rather than immediately presenting a conclusion. He summarized the lesson this way: “Buyers don't believe the claims we make, they believe the conclusions that they reach on their own.” That is a useful principle for examining your marketing. A company can repeatedly describe itself as dependable, but a buyer still needs a basis for judging that claim. A concrete example of how the company handled a difficult delivery may provide that basis. A clear explanation of the process may help. So might a relevant customer reference or documentation that answers a specific concern. The buyer gains something to evaluate. Gee described the broader intention as: “We're not trying to sell, we're trying to help people to buy.” Applied responsibly, that means giving buyers accurate information, explaining relevant trade-offs, and making it easier to assess whether an offering fits their situation. It should never mean withholding material information to steer someone toward a predetermined answer. The strongest version of this approach respects the buyer’s ability to make an informed decision. Generic Marketing Leaves Buyers with Too Little to Evaluate Gee used familiar stock photography as an example of communication that can feel interchangeable: the same headset-wearing representative appearing on unrelated company websites. His point was about the distance between the image a company presents and the reality a buyer is trying to understand. Generic copy creates a similar problem. Consider these statements: - “We deliver industry-leading solutions.” - “Our team provides exceptional service.” - “We are your trusted partner for growth.” Each statement is positive. None explains much. What does the company do differently? Which problem does it understand? What happens when something goes wrong? What evidence supports the promise? AI can make producing language like this easier. That makes editorial judgment more important. Publishing more statements does little for credibility if those statements contain no additional substance. A practical test is to remove your company name from a paragraph. Could a competitor publish it unchanged? If the answer is yes, the paragraph may need more specific knowledge, evidence, or perspective. Make Someone Accountable for the Finished Work Gee argued that a visibly careless passage can undermine otherwise strong communication. “People judge the whole piece by the worst sentence in it.” His wording is deliberately pointed. The practical lesson is to review the whole experience, including the parts that may seem too minor to deserve attention. An unsupported claim can create doubt. An inaccurate detail can distract from a useful explanation. A message that uses the wrong context can make a prospect question whether the sender understands them at all. The publishing standard should therefore extend beyond grammar and tone. Before releasing AI-assisted marketing, an accountable person should check: Accuracy: Are the facts, names, descriptions, and examples correct? Evidence: Can the business support the promises being made? Relevance: Does the piece address a recognizable buyer question or problem? Specificity: Does it contain information beyond broad descriptions of excellence? Voice: Does it sound like something the organization can credibly stand behind? The tool may help produce the material. Responsibility for publishing it stays with the business. Replace Inflated Claims with Verifiable Evidence Gee’s most immediately useful recommendation was to choose one piece of outbound marketing and remove exaggerated, unsupported claims. Then replace them with information a buyer can check. “Substitute it for a fact that a buyer could actually go and check and verify.” That changes the writing task. Instead of asking how to describe your business more impressively, ask what evidence would help someone understand its value. The following are illustrative editing directions, not claims about any particular company: Broad claim A more useful direction “Industry-leading service” Explain the support process, escalation path, and commitments you actually provide. “We help businesses grow” Describe a documented client problem, the work completed, and the resulting change. “The highest-quality solution” Identify the relevant testing, specifications, or standards a buyer can inspect. “Trusted by customers” Offer an attributable customer example or reference, with permission. “Decades of experience” Explain how that experience informs a decision or helps solve the buyer’s current problem. Specificity should not become an excuse to invent numbers or overstate causation. A modest, documented result is more useful than an impressive claim the business cannot substantiate. If a client outcome depended on several factors, acknowledge the context. If you cannot name the client, explain what you can share without implying independent verification that is unavailable. Show What Happened for a Real Customer Gee encouraged leaders to move from adjectives to an actual customer experience: “Swap all of that stuff for a specific thing that happened for a specific client.” A clear customer example gives readers something concrete to understand. It does not need an elaborate production. Start with four elements: The situation What was the client trying to accomplish? What obstacle made that difficult? The work What did your team actually do? Explain the relevant actions without burying them in jargon. The outcome What changed? Use records, customer confirmation, or other appropriate evidence to support the description. The relevance Why might this experience matter to someone facing a similar problem? Where might the circumstances differ? This structure helps a buyer evaluate your experience without requiring them to accept a sweeping promise. It also gives the people creating your content a stronger source. A documented customer story contains details that a generic instruction to “write persuasive marketing copy” cannot supply. Ask How AI Can Increase Customer Value Another theme in our conversation was the way leaders frame technology decisions. Gee challenged the tendency to begin and end with cost reduction. He asked leaders to consider a different question: “What can we now do that we couldn't do before?” That question opens a broader discussion about the purpose of adopting a tool. Alongside efficiency, a team might explore whether a proposed workflow could help it organize recurring customer questions, identify gaps in existing materials, or make approved information easier to find. Those are possibilities to test against the business’s actual needs and quality requirements. The important step is to define the customer benefit before declaring the implementation a success. For example, if a team proposes a faster content workflow, ask: - Which buyer question will we answer better? - What information will make that answer credible? - Who will verify it? - How will we know the finished piece was useful? - What would cause us to revise or stop the workflow? A reduction in production time can be valuable. It tells only part of the story. Understand the Work Before You Automate It Gee also cautioned that a job description may not capture everything a person contributes. People often exercise judgment that is difficult to see in a task list. They recognize an unusual customer request, catch a misleading phrase, remember an exception, or consult someone before a small issue becomes a larger one. His concern points to a practical leadership responsibility: understand the workflow in enough detail to know where that judgment occurs. Before changing a process, ask the people doing the work: - Which situations require you to depart from the usual steps? - What mistakes do you routinely catch? - What context do you use that is not written down? - When do you involve another person? - What would a successful handoff need to include? Those answers help distinguish repetitive steps from decisions that require context. They also create a better basis for evaluating any proposed automation. Efficiency gains should be considered alongside accuracy, review effort, rework, and the customer experience. A One-Hour Marketing Credibility Audit Gee ended our conversation with an action leaders can take this week: improve one existing piece of marketing. Choose something a buyer will actually encounter—a cold email, a homepage section, a sales slide, or a service description. Here is a practical way to carry out that exercise. First 10 minutes: Identify the buyer’s question Write down what the reader needs to understand or decide. Be specific. “Learn about our company” is less useful than “Determine whether we can support an implementation without disrupting their current operations.” Next 10 minutes: Mark the unsupported claims Highlight words such as “best,” “leading,” “seamless,” “trusted,” and “exceptional.” For each one, ask what the reader can inspect or verify. Remove claims that cannot be supported. Next 20 minutes: Add concrete evidence Replace the weakest passage with an accurate example, a clear process explanation, or a documented result. Use information the organization is authorized to share. Keep the detail relevant to the buyer’s question. Next 10 minutes: Make the language natural Read the piece aloud. Simplify wording you would not use in a real conversation. Look for repetition, unnecessary jargon, and sentences that sound substantial but contain little information. Final 10 minutes: Review from the buyer’s perspective Ask someone who was not involved in writing it: - What did you learn? - What would you still question? - Which statement felt least credible? - Does the piece help you decide what to do next? The result should be a clearer, more useful communication—not simply a shorter one. Buyer Trust Is a Leadership Responsibility My conversation with Gee returned repeatedly to respect for the person receiving the message. A buyer is trying to understand a problem, evaluate options, and decide whom to trust. Marketing should help with that work. Leaders influence whether it does. They decide what gets rewarded, what standards apply, and whether a faster publishing process still includes meaningful review. If the organization measures only how much content it produces, the team has little guidance about what makes that content worth reading. Start with one piece. Remove an unsupported claim. Add something real. Make the next decision easier for the person on the other side. That is a practical way to connect better marketing with better leadership. Watch or listen to Gee Ranasinha’s conversation, “AI Slop Is Killing Buyer Trust,” on The Leadership Match for more on marketing psychology, credible communication, and creating customer value.

All articles