Leadership Mindset: Change Your Story | Elaine Powell
By The Leadership Match
Elaine Powell explores how leadership mindset shapes behavior, trust, and decisions—and how leaders can question assumptions and act with greater awareness.
Leadership Mindset: How the Story You Tell Yourself Shapes the Way You Lead Lessons from Elaine Powell on self-awareness, integrity, and turning insight into action By Martin Rowinski | The Leadership Match An employee questions your decision in a meeting. You interpret it as a challenge to your authority. A client takes longer than expected to respond. You begin wondering whether you have lost their confidence. A presentation does not go as planned. Instead of examining what needs improvement, you start questioning whether you belong in the role. In each situation, something happened. Then you gave it meaning. That distinction was at the center of my conversation with keynote speaker and thought disruptor Elaine Powell on The Leadership Match. We explored how the stories leaders tell themselves can influence their decisions, relationships, and willingness to grow. Elaine’s message was practical: before you can change a pattern, you need to recognize the interpretation helping to sustain it. “But you have to notice the story before you can interrupt it.” For leaders, that means paying attention to more than what happens around you. It means examining what you assume those events say about you, your team, and your future. What Is Leadership Mindset—and Why Does It Matter? Leadership mindset is the collection of beliefs, assumptions, and interpretations that influences how a leader approaches people and decisions. It becomes visible through behavior. A leader who believes every disagreement signals disloyalty may discourage honest feedback. Someone who assumes they must always have the answer may struggle to ask for help. A manager who treats a mistake as evidence of personal inadequacy may become defensive when a team needs an open review. These are examples of how interpretation can shape a response. They do not mean that every workplace problem originates in someone’s thinking. Unclear responsibilities, insufficient resources, and harmful behavior require concrete attention. The value of examining leadership mindset is that it helps separate those practical problems from assumptions that may be making them harder to address. Elaine encouraged leaders to become more aware of that internal process: “Some of them are in my blind spots, and I can't see them.” Her acknowledgment matters. Self-awareness is ongoing work, including for people who teach it. Leadership Integrity Starts with Keeping Your Word Before discussing internal narratives, Elaine described an experience that changed her relationship with leadership: a seven-month development program that placed integrity beneath the rest of its leadership principles. She recognized that she had sometimes made commitments without following through, then supplied reasons or excuses. Her reflection was candid: “I saw that at the time I had a very weak relationship with my word.” For a leader, a commitment creates an expectation in someone else’s working life. An employee may be waiting for feedback before submitting a proposal. A colleague may have organized a project around an agreed deadline. A customer may be making plans based on a promised update. Forgetting the commitment does not remove its impact. Elaine emphasized the importance of addressing promises that had not been honored. A practical application is to review outstanding commitments regularly and take responsibility when circumstances change. That can mean: - Clarifying exactly what you have agreed to deliver. - Recording the commitment somewhere reliable. - Communicating early if you cannot meet it. - Acknowledging the effect of a missed promise. - Agreeing on a realistic next step and following through. Leadership integrity becomes tangible through these repeated actions. People learn whether your words provide a dependable basis for their own decisions. Separate What Happened from What You Made It Mean One of the most revealing parts of the conversation concerned Elaine’s relationship with her mother. Elaine recalled being compared with her sister when she was younger. She interpreted those comparisons as meaning that her mother did not accept her for who she was. That interpretation contributed to a strained relationship. Later, through coaching and a direct conversation, she was able to examine the distinction between what had been said and what she had concluded. “But I made it mean that she doesn't like me for who I am.” In Elaine’s account, her mother explained that she wanted her daughter to do well. Hearing that did not change the earlier events, but it gave Elaine information that challenged the meaning she had attached to them. The workplace application is significant. Consider an employee who misses a deadline. The observable fact is that the agreed work was not delivered on time. “They do not respect me” is an interpretation. “They are no longer committed” is another. Either interpretation might influence how the leader approaches the conversation before learning what happened. A more useful starting point is to separate three things: Question Example What can I observe? The proposal was due Tuesday and has not arrived. What am I assuming? The employee does not take the work seriously. What do I need to clarify? What prevented delivery, and what is needed now? This does not excuse missed expectations. It gives the leader a better foundation for addressing them. Take Ownership Without Assuming All the Blame Elaine described approaching the conversation with her mother by taking responsibility for her own side of the relationship. “But I took ownership of our relationship from my side.” That is a useful distinction for leaders. Ownership does not require accepting responsibility for everything another person does. It means examining your contribution and being willing to change what is within your control. In a difficult working relationship, that might involve asking: - Have I explained my expectations clearly? - Have I checked my interpretation with the other person? - Am I reacting to this situation or to a pattern I expect to see? - What have I done that may have made communication harder? For example, a manager frustrated by a colleague’s lack of initiative might discover that they routinely revise the colleague’s decisions without explaining why. The colleague may have learned that waiting for direction is safer than acting independently. The manager still needs to discuss ownership and performance. But recognizing their own contribution creates another way to improve the situation. Authentic Leadership Makes Learning Visible Elaine identified the pressure to appear as though everything is under control as a barrier to growth. Leaders can become so concerned about how they are perceived that they hide uncertainty, avoid acknowledging mistakes, or speak about development only in abstract terms. Her alternative was to show how learning actually happens: “That's where the growth is, is being vulnerable and showing when things aren't working and how did you work your way through it?” Useful leadership vulnerability has a purpose. It helps people understand a situation, learn from experience, or contribute to a solution. A leader might say: “I assumed we had enough capacity for this deadline. I did not check that carefully enough. Let’s review the workload and agree on a plan we can deliver.” That statement acknowledges a mistake while maintaining responsibility for the next step. Authenticity does not require sharing every private concern or asking employees to manage the leader’s emotions. It requires enough honesty for the team to work with reality. Meet People Where They Are Before Asking Them to Change Elaine also discussed how she approaches speaking and teaching. If a speaker presents themselves as far removed from the audience’s struggles, people may find the advice difficult to connect with. Elaine uses storytelling to establish that connection before introducing tools and strategies. She described the goal as leaving people: “More equipped with tools and strategies, not just inspiration.” The same principle applies to leadership development. Telling a new manager to “be more confident” gives them little to practice. Understanding where they hesitate creates a more useful starting point. Perhaps they struggle to open a difficult conversation. They may need a clear structure, an opportunity to rehearse, and feedback afterward. A leader asking a team to adopt a new process should first understand what the current process demands of them. The obstacle may be confusion, competing priorities, or previous experience with changes that were never fully supported. Meeting people where they are means identifying the actual starting point. From there, development can become specific. Notice, Interrupt, Reframe, and Act Elaine described a sequence for working with unhelpful stories: notice the pattern, interrupt it, create a different interpretation, and take a new action. A practical leadership exercise based on that discussion looks like this. 1. Notice the interpretation Choose a recent moment when you felt defensive, discouraged, or reluctant to act. Ask yourself what you were saying internally. Was it “They do not trust me,” “I should already know this,” or “If I ask for help, I will look incapable”? Treat the response as something to examine rather than an established fact. 2. Interrupt the automatic response Pause before sending the defensive email, withdrawing from the discussion, or taking the work back from someone else. Elaine mentioned talking with another person as one way to interrupt a pattern. In a leadership setting, that might mean consulting a trusted colleague or writing down the observable facts before deciding what to do. 3. Develop a more grounded interpretation The aim is not to replace an uncomfortable story with an unrealistically positive one. Instead of moving from “They are questioning my competence” to “Everyone agrees with me,” consider: “They have raised a concern I need to understand.” A useful reframe leaves room for evidence and inquiry. 4. Take an action that tests your assumption Ask a clarifying question. Request specific feedback. Confirm expectations. Discuss the obstacle directly. The action creates an opportunity to learn something that thinking alone cannot resolve. Respond to Self-Doubt with Evidence Elaine shared that an old school experience had contributed to a recurring negative judgment about her own intelligence. Even with evidence of professional capability, the thought could still reappear. She described recognizing that voice and looking for evidence that challenged it. For leaders, this offers a practical way to examine broad self-judgments. “I handled that meeting poorly” identifies an event that can be reviewed. “I am a poor leader” turns it into a sweeping conclusion. The first statement allows useful questions: - Where did the conversation become unclear? - What preparation was missing? - What feedback would help? - What should I do differently next time? Elaine described her preferred way of thinking about failure as: “Learning how to do it better the next time.” That framing can support accountability by keeping attention on what needs to change. It does not erase consequences. It makes improvement more specific than self-criticism. Make Thinking Part of Leadership Development When I asked Elaine what leaders could do to elevate their teams’ thinking, she urged organizations to invest in internal development alongside technical skills. Sales techniques, marketing knowledge, and presentation skills matter. So does the ability to question an assumption, receive feedback, or recognize when fear of being wrong is preventing a useful conversation. Leaders can incorporate that development into existing work: - During a project review, ask which assumptions proved inaccurate. - In a coaching conversation, distinguish an observed behavior from an inferred motive. - Before a major decision, ask what evidence could change the team’s view. - After a mistake, discuss the reasoning that led to it as well as the outcome. - When someone raises a concern, explore it before defending the original plan. These practices make reflection part of the way work gets done. Change One Leadership Story This Week Elaine’s conversation brought together two responsibilities: honoring the commitments we make to others and examining the interpretations that influence our behavior. Both require attention. A leader needs to notice when their actions have fallen short and when their assumptions are shaping a response before the facts are clear. Start with one situation that keeps frustrating you. Write down what happened. Then write down what you have decided it means. Identify what you know, what remains uncertain, and which conversation could help you understand the difference. You may confirm that a practical problem needs to be addressed. You may discover that your interpretation was incomplete. Either way, you will be better positioned to choose your next action. Watch or listen to Elaine Powell’s conversation, “The Story You Tell Yourself Is Controlling Your Leadership,” on The Leadership Match for more on leadership mindset, authenticity, and self-awareness.
All articles